[See part 1 for bibliography] ****Who Invented Unsharp Masking?**** [Hunt, p263] "Another useful feature often used in masking was first suggested by Yule (Yule, 1944). Exact registration of the mask when bound up with the original is obviously difficult, and if not perfectly achieved results in halos appearing around any well-defined edges. Yule suggested that the masks should be made deliberately *unsharp* by printing them with a thin spacer between the transparency and the mask material. This not only helps to obscure slight lack of registration of the masks, but also improves the reproduction of fine detail. A negative mask reduces contrast, but fine detail is seen more clearly if reproduced at high contrast; by having the mask unsharp the fine detail is not resolved by the mask and hence, when it is bound up with the original transparency, it does not reduce the contrast of fine detail, but only of large areas." [Yule, p74] "Color-correcting masks should be made somewhat unsharp; for example by the use of a diffusion sheet (Spiegler and Juris, 1931 and 1933; Yule, 1944). This makes the registration of the masks less critical, and it improves the sharpness of the detail in the reproduction." ****Moire and Overlapping Absorption Bands**** [Yule, p343] "It is often said that the yellow printer does not usually cause noticable patterns because its color is so light. Although there is some truth in this, Pollak (1958, 1959) has shown that it is more a question of overlapping absorption bands. Each wavelength of light produces moire patterns independantly, and what we see is the sum of all of these. If only one halftone print absorbed light at each wavelength, there would be no pattern. A pattern is produced because of the overlapping absorption bands of the inks. The absorption band of the black ink, which covers the whole spectrum, is bound to overlap with all three of the other inks. At wavelengths where the magenta and cyan both absorb light (mainly in the green region of the spectrum), a moire pattern will therefore be produced between the magenta, cyan, and black if the 30 or 60 degree angles are incorrect. This pattern will appear most pronounced if observed though a green filter." [Yule, p343-4] "When the yellow ink is at 45 degrees to the black, these two images will not form a noticeable moire pattern. The yellow is then at an angle of 15 degrees to the other two colors, and it will normally form a small moire pattern with either one if the absorption bands overlap, and a somewhat larger second-order pattern with both of them together if all three absorption bands overlap. The yellow ink absorbs light only in the blue region of the spectrum. With a reddish magenta and a greenish cyan, both of which absorb blue light, a more noticeable pattern will be produced by interaction with the yellow ink than when bluish magenta and cyan inks are used. With a clean bluish cyan, in fact, the moire pattern formed between the cyan and yellow may be so weak that they can both be printed at the same angle without intorducing much variation from sheet to sheet on account of register changes." ****Moire and Color Shifts**** [Yule, p335] "It might be thought that the best way to avoid moire patterns would be to print all the halftones at exactly the same angle. This would not be satisfactory because the color produced would depend on whether the dots fell on top of each other or side by side. With the dots on top of each other, a much lighter tone would be produced, because there would be a much larger area of unprinted white paper. The color produced would therefore be extremely sensitive to minute variations in register." [Yule, p339] [Describing screens not quite 60 degrees apart] "In some parts, rosettes of dots are formed with a single dot in the center (composed of three superimposed dots). Elsewhere, double rings of dots with a clear center are produced. In the latter case, the centers of the clear openings are superimposed. Between these two extremes, irregular patterns of dots are formed." "If the screen angles in Fig. 13.07B had been exactly 60 degrees, the moire pattern would have become infinitely large. The dot arrangement would be similar over the whole sheet. It might be dot-centered or clear-centered, or it might have the irregular intermediate pattern. A shift in register of only half a screen period would shift it from one to the other. With the clear-centered pattern, there would be no point at which three dots were exactly superimposed; and with the dot-centered pattern, the centers of the clear openings would never coincide. The relative areas of the eight colored components of the pattern would change with this shift in register, and consequently the color would change slightly. This always occurs in four-color printing, especially when there is much black in the middletones, but it is usually not distinguished from other causes of color balance shifts. It becomes very noticable when an error in screen angle brings the different patterns close to one another in the form of moire." [Yule, p341-2] "It is, however, if practical importance that shifting one of the screens by a distance of only half a screen period (usually about 0.004 inch) will convert the pattern from a dot-centered one to a clear-centered one, which produces a color shift if the absorption bands of all three inks overlap. The differences in color are quite small (corresponding to a difference in green-filter density of about 0.04 in the middletones for typical good quality magenta, cyan, and black inks), but they are very noticable when they occur in a moire pattern." [Yule, p342] "One interesting consequence of this is that printing a black halftone over a neutral three-color gray (composed of cyan, magenta, and yellow) can make it slightly greenish or pinkish depending on the register of the dots. Another consequence is that gray-balance measurements (with yellow, magenta, and cyan inks) will be unreliable if 30 and 60 degree angles are used in the test object. In this case, the blue-filter density is the one which is variable, resulting in slight blue-yellow color shifts." "The dot-centered and clear-centered patterns are complimentary to each other in that dot-centered highlights will be accompanied by a configuration in the shadows like the clear-centered pattern. The small openings in each of the halftones are seen as dots in the shadows, and these are arranged in a ring as in the clear-centered pattern." "The formula for the period of the moire pattern (Eq 13.01) shows that with a 150-line-per-inch screen, an error of half a degree will produce a pattern with a period of 0.75 inch, which is very noticable. The angles should be accurate within +/- 0.1 degree, which will give a pattern with a period of nearly 4 inches. This will not be visible except in large uniform areas. The pattern is most noticable in a medium gray with a dot area of about 50% in the cyan, magenta, and black printers." "Even if the angles are exactly correct, this pattern is still troublesome, since a slight variation in registration of the three colors will cause a change on color from sheet to sheet (Pollak, 1955a). This must occur consistently in four-color printing, but it appears unavoidable and is usually unnoticed. It provides an additional argument against carrying black in the middletones of the picture. With a skeleton black plate, the tones containing black are so dark that the pattern is not noticable." [Yule, p344] "In conventional gravure printing, there is very little halftone pattern and all colors may be printed at the same angle. This has been suggested even for the halftone gravure process, such as the Dultgen process, which have a much more pronounced dot pattern. It should be remembered, however, that when all the angles are the same, the moire pattern is of infinite size, and what occurs is not a visible moire pattern but a change of color from sheet to sheet as the register changes. Large, irregular blotches of varying hue, due to local distortions, are also seen. To determine how serious this is, a proof should be made with two of the halftones at slightly incorrect angles. The intensity of the moire pattern thus produced will be a measure of the sheet-to-sheet variation to be expected."