Category: Auto Industry

Not Enough Bullets: Chrysler/Fiat

It appears that Fiat may be the employer of record for senior management, and that they will then be “seconded” to Chrysler in order to skirt pay limitations at bailed out firms. (See also here)

In the long run, the real answer is confiscatory taxes at higher levels of remuneration.

Figure bumping the tax rate by 1% at $250K/year and at each $250K break point, with a limit of 85% at income in excess of $13¼ million a year, or 90% at 14½ million a year.

This crap needs to stop. These executives are overpaid by the standards of the world, they will be making more than the Chairman of Fiat, which is taking them over, and they do not deliver value.

The problem is not excessive salaries for senior executives at bailed out firms, it is excessive salaries, period, full stop.

It is theft from the shareholders and the less well remunerated employees, and it is corrosive to society.

Auto Update

First, let’s be clear that the domestic auto makers problems are not just incompetent management. No one is making money selling cars right now, not even Toyota, which posted its first quarterly loss in 59 years, $7.74 billion in the quarter ending in March, and, as the picture shows, is looking at more losses in the future, while Nissan posted a $2.4 billion loss.

Of course, the sight of GM executives frantically selling stocks as a trading window opened to allow them to sell their stocks without insider trading concerns.

They are also sending terms of sale sheets to the dozen or so bidders for the Saturn brand brand. It’s primarily the sale of a dealer network and brand, rather than a sale of designs or factories.

Meanwhile, across the pond, Fiat is still negotiating a deal to buy GM’s Opel division, and most of this is about how much can be extracted from the German government.

At the nexus of the two failed auto makers, both GM and Chrysler will be cutting dealers, which makes sense, and it’s the urban dealers that will see most of the cuts, which, surprise means that minority owned dealerships will see it landing them.

Same old, same old.

In any case, it now appears that the 2 month bankruptcy is a fiction, with media reports that the bankruptcy will take 2 years, though the sale of assets to the new operating company should be finished well before this.

Meanwhile, Ford, which saw the storm coming, and accumulated cash to weather it, is now looking to sell 300 million shares of common stock in order to fund the Voluntary Employee Beneficiary Association (VEBA) that it negotiated with the UAW.

Finally, we have Ferrari threatening to pull out of Formula One because they do not like the new rules, most particularly the £40 million budget cap, which is intended to make more teams competitive.

Yet Another Auto Industry Update

First and foremost, it looks like GM will be dropped from the Dow Jones Industrial average, no surprise with GM trading at around a buck and a half.

For the same reason, GM is looking at a 1-For-100 reverse stock split, which is no surprise, as the troubled automaker was trading at over $50 a share just 2 years ago.

Seeing as how GM bled $6 billion in the last quarter, the reverse stock split is prudent.

Meanwhile, the Chrysler bankruptcy is proceeding rather smoothly, see here, and here.

The judge has generally ruled against the sanctimony of the “non-TARP lenders,” whose numbers has dwindled, and the fact that their names will be revealed has made think twice about being jerks.

Meanwhile Fiat has been busy after having taken a stake in Chrysler, and is now looking to purchase GM Europe, aka Opel, and spin off its own auto manufacture in Italy to incorporate in their new larger auto manufacturing concern. (See also here)

I Hope that They Are Lying

the Chrysler creditors, the ones who pushed the automaker into Chapter 11, are claiming that the White House threatened the reputations of the firms involved in order to get them to accede to their demands

In an interview with a Detroit radio host, Frank Beckmann, Mr. Lauria said that Perella Weinberg “was directly threatened by the White House and in essence compelled to withdraw its opposition to the deal under threat that the full force of the White House press corps would destroy its reputation if it continued to fight.”

I hope that the WH was threatening to destroy the reputations of the firms involved.

Shame is a legitimate tactic to coerce cooperation, though the idea that Obama would use the, “full force of the White House press corps,” is absurd on its face.

Now to start playing hardball with Goldman Sachs.

Remind Me Never to Play Poker With Barack Obama

Because that’s just what happened with the Chrysler bankruptcy, as this article titled Chrysler Lenders Tried Obama’s Patience, Lost Game of Chicken shows.

They are making noises about how unfairly they have been treated:

An anonymous group of 20 Chrysler lenders calling itself the “Committee of Chrysler Non-Tarp Lenders” said in a statement yesterday that they’d been treated worse than junior creditors during negotiations in violation of “long-recognized legal and business principles.” They said they were owed $1 billion.

And they are technically correct that they are secured creditors, but their security is not equal the full value of the loans, more like 10-20% of the outstanding amount, and they are vulture capitalists who intended this shakedown in the first place, as evidence by the fact that they, “paid from 50 cents to 70 cents on the dollar for their Chrysler loans,” (my money is actually on their purchasing this debt for less than 50¢ on the dollar).

Now they are whining, and they are the ones who will be taken into court and have the fingers pointed at them.

This is a very big shot across the bow for creditors for General Motors.

In completely unrelated auto news, the April sales figures are out, and they are bleak, with GM -33%, Ford -32%, Honda -25%, Nissan -38%, Hyundai -14%, Daimler -31%, and Toyota -42% year over year.

Auto Industry Update

Well Chrysler had gone Chapter 11, because of the unwillingness of a number of the smaller creditors to negotiate in good faith.

Those folks are actually better described as hedge funds, and knowing how hedgies work, they doubtless bought debt at a discount for the express purpose of holding it for ransom.

Here is hoping that the BK judge cleans them out.

Meanwhile, back in GM land, its bondholders have made a counter-offer, wanting a 58% stake in the firm, as opposed to the 10% stake offered, so there is a big gap to bridge there too.

Auto Industry Update (Chrysler and Dealers)

Well, it looks like the Chrysler/Fiat thing is a done deal, though this would likely be post bankruptcy, because they cannot get the smaller creditors on to agree to concessions:

The Obama administration last night planned to send Chrysler into bankruptcy, replace chief executive Robert L. Nardelli* and pump billions of dollars more into the effort, all in hopes the company can emerge from court proceedings as a reenergized competitor in the global economy.

Government officials clung to 11th-hour hopes last night that bankruptcy could be averted, but talks broke down with Chrysler’s creditors. A bankruptcy filing could happen as soon as today.

The U.S. government’s attempt to save the automaker amounts to another extraordinary intervention in the economy and a landmark event in the history of the American auto industry.

Under the administration’s detailed court strategy, ownership of Chrysler would be dramatically reorganized, the leadership of Italian automaker Fiat would take over company management and the U.S. and Canadian governments would contribute more than $10 billion in additional funding.

I would note that Cerberus would be completely wiped out on this deal, and be left with nothing, but they are not complaining, since they bought Chrysler to flip it to GM, and then found themselves having to run it when GM had its own crisis, and the alternative, that various parties go after them is even less palatable.

In related news, the dealers for both Chrysler, with the aid of the NADA, are lawyering up to deal with the consequences of a bankruptcy, which would void their franchise agreements.

Cutting dealerships is necessary, as Chrysler has about 2¾ times as many dealers per car sale as Toyota, which adds costs and inefficiencies to the system.

*Full disclosure, I worded at GE Transportation Systems (GETS) their locomotive manufacturing unit from 1994-1996, and for about half of my time there, the chief of the division was Bob Nardelli, who I have never met.

Auto Industry Update

Well, Honda automobile lost money, though the whole operation made a slight profit because of their motorcycle business.

Meanwhile, GM is having problems negotiating its bondholders, with the troubled automaker giving what says is a “final offer,” and the bond holders are blowing a gasket over this:

Today’s posturing makes it clear that the company and the auto task force would rather discount the thousands of individual investors and retirees who own GM bonds than undergo earnest negotiations.

I think that the bond holders think that they can do with GM what was done with GMAC, throw a tantrum, and get what they want, but the market has already discounted these bonds by over 85%, and the offer is a better deal than that.

On Chrysler’s side, things look better with both the UAW and the bondholders coming to agreements with the auto firm.

The UAW will a get 55% equity stake in Chrysler, in exchange for concessions, but I’m still a pessimist, and believe that they are getting 55% of what will turn out to be nothing.

I think that the bondholders for GM have unrealistic expectations of the carmaker’s survival.

I would say that even if GM gets the bondholders to an agreement, they still have to figure out how to cut dealerships without declaring bankruptcy.

Getting out of those franchise agreements would be difficult otherwise, unless Congress gets into the act to streamline the process, which I do not expect, since car dealers are big political donors.

General Motors Update

The big news is that the Firebird is dead, as GM will eliminate Pontiac, though it is keeping GMC.

I wonder if they will look for a legislative fix to minimize the costs of winding it down, as GM had to pay billions to dealers when it wound down Oldsmobile a few years back.

Additionally, they gust got $2 billion more lent to them, which implies that the folks looking at this on the automotive task force think that they are getting their sh&% together.

Economics Update

The British economy just posted its largest quarterly loss since 1979, 1.9 % for the quarter, and 4.1% year over year.

We had Moody’s downgrade American Express debt from A2 to A3, because of lower earnings from fewer purchases made with its cards, and more bad loans.

Unsurprisingly, the same thing is happening with the stress tested banks, where PNC Financial says that bad assets are expected to triple.

We do have some good news with Ford Motors beating expectations, though the numbers are still awful, and corporate borrowing costs falling below last October’s numbers.

In currency, the dollar weakened again, and this had traders bidding up the price of oil.

Auto Industry Update

It now appears that the sale of GM’s main European division is a done deal, and it also looks possible that they will essentially give the car company away, “According to a person familiar with GM’s thinking, an investor will be asked to pay at least €500m ($652m) in equity but the carmaker will realise no financial gain as the money will be injected directly into Opel.”

I note without surprise that Cerberus, the private equity firm that owns Chrysler, is not interested in getting a piece of this deal.

When Cerberus bought Chrysler, they expected to hold onto it for perhaps 6 months, and then sell it to GM. Their model was flip and flee, not sensibly operate a company as a going concern.

Meanwhile, on the worker benefits front, it looks like GM Sand the UAW will be renegotiating their benefits deal, replacing much of the cash promised with an ownership stock in GM.

There is very little that I am sure of, but one is that when employees get an ownership stake in lieu of payment, they get the shaft.

In other GM News, it now appears that the normal 2 week end of year shutdown will be extended to 9 weeks, which makes sense when you look at how moribund car sales are, and they spooked the market by saying that was unlikely that they would be making a $1 billion debt payment in July, though they are saying that this is because they will have restructured the debt.

There is also a report that the US government will move to convert GM’s debt to it into equity, which will likely make the taxpayer the largest shareholder of the automotive giant.

Meanwhile, the Treasury is directing Chrysler to prepare for a bankruptcy filing, and not because, as the chattering class is so fond of asserting, the union is being unreasonable, but because the banks and other debt holders are.

Chrysler lenders offer to cut debt, take stock – Apr. 21, 2009, see here,
here, here, and here.

Basically, the market value on their debt is about 15%, and they want something north of 85%.

Picking Industry Insiders for their “Experience” is Such a Good Idea

Because the corporate raider that Barack Obama has put in charge of the auto industry bailout has now been tied to a kickback scheme involving the New York state pension fund:

The man leading the Obama administration’s efforts to restructure the auto industry has been described in Securities and Exchange Commission documents as having arranged for his investment firm to pay more than $1 million to obtain New York State pension business.

Although he is not named in the documents, a person with knowledge of the inquiry said the investment executive is Steven Rattner, co-founder of the Quadrangle Group, the prominent private equity firm

Gee….Hoocoodanode that a man who is a corporate chop shop might be ethically challenged.

This is why expertise does not trump ethics and philosophy. Summers, Geithner, Rattner, etc. are all either wrong doers, or were until recently in the pay or wrong doers, and are largely responsible for the problem.

It’s like making an arsonist for hire your fire department chief.

Economics Update


Scary Picture of the Day, Industrial Production, Courtesy of Naked Capitalism

The big news is that there are rumors of GM preparing for bankruptcy, and mark my words, if they do go into bankruptcy, it will be because of the bond holders, not the union, and I do not see it working as a prepackaged filing, so we would see massive disruptions amongst all the auto plants of all brands in the US.

Were it not for the GM rumors, the lede would be the continued implosion of consumer credit, with grim February reports showing that U.S. consumer credit falling by $7.48 billion, an annual rate of 3.5%, and homeowner mortgage default rates have increased to 7%, up more than 50% from a year ago.

That being said, it’s not just consumers and homeowners in trouble, as the default rate of “speculative-grade corporate borrowers” hit the highest rate since the depression in March.

Meanwhile in a harbinger of things to come in commercial real estate, New York City office rents fell 6% in the Q1 of 2009, and the vacancy rate is at 9.6%, up from 6.1% a year ago.

It is therefore unsurprising that the Business Roundtable’s survey of CEOs is showing falling confidence.

In the meantime, uncertainty, particularly the GM rumors have driven both the Yen and the US Dollar up, and has driven oil down.

Auto Industry Update

Once again, it looks like the management at Ford did everything right to face this crisis, and they have executed debt for equity swaps and haircuts to bondholders that has lowered their outstanding debt by $9.9 billion, and lowered their interest payments by about $550 million a year.

On the other side of doing the right thing, we have GM, who says that they
expect to sell their SAAB automobile division by the end of June, as there are 3-5 serious bidders.

I never understood this merger in the first place, SAAB auto was too small for GM, and unlike Ford’s purchase of Jaguar, where Ford’s quality was marked superior, and was applied to the British sports care maker, GM didn’t have anything of value to send to SAAB.

Meanwhile, I get to say a sentence that I rarely get to say, that “The New Republic gets it,”on the auto bailout.

The problem is not the unions. It’s the bondholders and banks who are unwilling to deal.

Economics Update

We have the weekly unemployment claims report, and it is not pretty, with 669,000 new claims, an increase of 12,000, the 4 week moving average was up 6,500 to 656,750, and the continuing claims hit 5,728,000, up 161,000.

Note that the initial claims number constitutes a 26½ year high, and continuing claims are at the 9th all time record level in 9 weeks.

Meanwhile, the credit news is not good, with Calculated Risk’s Credit Crisis Indicators somewhat improved, though still at pretty awful levels, but Moody’s downgraded $1.76 trillion in corporate debt in the first quarter of 2009, and both credit card charge-offs and home equity loan delinquencies have climbed to record levels.

In real estate commercial real estate defaults hit a new record, and the formerly unassailable real estate of Manhattan is sales volume falling 48%, though house prices rose in the UK for the first time since 2007.

Additionally, the Feds efforts to lower mortgage rates appear to be working, with the 30 year fixed mortgage rate hitting a new low.

In the meantime, auto industry analysts are doing handsprings over the March auto sales figures, because annualized sales figures rose to 9.86 million up from February’s rate of 9.12 million, though dealer incentives also rose 5%.

Your call as to whether an 8% increase of awful, the normal annual sales runs at about 16 million, is something to crow about.

In either case, other manufacturing had an uptick, with Chinese manufacturing increasing for the first time in 4 months, and US factory orders rising for the first time in 7 months.

In Yurp, the European Central Bank cut its rates by only 25 basis points (¼%), less than expected, and as a result the Euro strengthened vs the US dollar, though the ECB President has said that more rates might be forthcoming

In energy, the rising stock market (Dow above 8k for the first time in about 7 weeks) has driven oil higher.

Reports that GM Wants to Force GM Into Bankruptcy

We have reports that appear to be leaked from the White House that say that they want to see GM go through some sort of preplanned bankruptcy here, and here.

I don’t see this happening, and I tend to agree with Yves Smith’s analysis that says that this would be next to impossible, because you would have to essentially get all the creditors to agree ahead of time.

Smith suggests that a realistic timetable for a bankruptcy would be over a year, and the analysis of the cascade effect on auto parts suppliers is that no one in the United States, including Toyota, Nissan, and Honda, would be able to make automobiles for something on the order of a year, because it would force the already tightly strapped auto parts suppliers into bankruptcy too.

I see this as primarily a way to apply pressure to two parties, the UAW and Pimco, who runs the world’s largest bond fund.

I think that Pimco is particularly a problem. Their behavior in the GMAC bailout was to dig in their heels, and make everyone else take a haircut, and all indications are that they are doing the same thing with GM.

Economics Update

Well, the job loss report from payroll processor ADP is out, and according to them, there were 742,00 job losses in March, well above the 655K forecast.

Part of this is driven by continued declines in construction spending, as Calculated Risk notes and graphs (see graph pr0n).

As he notes, non-residential construction spending is following residential spending off a cliff.

There was also an increase in the NAR’s pending home sales index, though it remains firmly in the horrible range, at 82.1, up from 80.4, with 100 being the average level of pending home sales in 2001.

Still, mortgage applications are up again, though this is largely still refi activity.

The Institute for Supply Management’s Manufacturing Index mirrors the pending home sales index, in that it is up, to 36.3 from 35.8, but still in a firmly contracting posture, as 50 is neutral.

On the other side of the Pacific, we are seeing Japanese business confidence numbers fall to record lows.

The news in the auto industry, whether foreign or domestic is grim, with sales numbers for GM, Toyota, Ford, Chrysler, Honda, and Nissan all falling significantly.

We also see the Fed printing money to buy $6 billion in Treasuries, so as to keep the interest rates down.

In currency, the dollar is up on risk aversion again. Investors are concerned about the G-20 meeting, though I’m not sure if the concern is about nothing being done, or something being done….Maybe it’s a bit of both.

In energy, oil fell on strong inventory reports.

Big 3 (Big 2½) Update

So, the White House does not like GM’s or Chrysler’s reorganization plans, and has given GM 60 days, and Chrysler 30 days to come up with a better plan.

What’s more, they demanded, and got General Motors’ CEO Rick Wagoner’s resignation, and pretty much demanded some sort of alliance deal between Fiat and Chrysler.

The obvious question here is, “Why is the government insisting on Wagoner’s resignation, and not Bank of America’s Kenneth Lewis’s resignation?

In terms of Chrysler-Fiat, it appears that they have come to an agreement on a “framework” for their deal.

One wonders if this deal involves a haircut for Cerberus, which it should.

Economics Update

So, we have some mixed news on the state of consumers, consumer sentiment improved slightly, though it is still near historic lows, and incomes have fallen.

Since consumers are generally deleveraging, I would place more importance on the latter, case in point, is February automobile sales continuing to drop, with the replacement for the US auto fleet, fleet size divided by monthly sales, hitting 27 years.

Obviously, this is not a sustainable number, and I would expect car sales to improve at some point, though whether this in time for the Big 3 (Big 2½) is anyone’s guess.

In any case, it apperas that Japan is heading back toward a deflationary situation, with their January CPI figures showing no change.

In energy and currency, the dollar is up and oil and other commodities are down.

Economics Update

Thursday is new jobless day, and the numbers suck with new claims falling to a still very high 646,000 and continuing claims hitting a new record of 5.47 million, which is a new record….Again.

This implies that people are still unable to find jobs, but, for a while, at least, employers have run out of people to lay off….Delightful.

We also had the Leading Economic Indicators falling, though not as badly as the consensus prediction, and the Philadelphia Fed Business Outlook Survey for March remained awful, from -41.3 in February to -35.0 this month, so we are still seeing a contraction.

In the auto industry, the bailout has been extended to parts suppliers, to the tune of %5 billion.

In real estate, it looks like Moody’s might cut the ratings on some $241 billion of debt for jumbo mortgages, which means that it must suck to live in a high cost real estate area right now.

In the world of the here and now, Moody’s did downgrade insurance company Prudential, and I’m wondering how long before the rest of the insurance industry looks like AIG.

In any case, it appears that the Fed’s decision to start quantitative easing (printing money) is having an effect, with the cost of borrowing falling, with 30-year fixed mortgages falling to 4.98%.

The Fed has also driven the US dollar lower, with the dollar hitting $1.36:€1.00 for the first time since January.

We are also hearing rumors that Citi is considering a reverse stock split, my guess is that this is how they want to address the worry that they might become a penny stock.

In energy, oil broke $50/bbl for the first time this year, on the falling dollar and reports that OPEC members are more-or-less keeping to their quotas.